Completist author reading, Old School

5 1/2. Agnes Grey – 7/10

Agnes Grey has all the features of the first book of a gifted writer. The topic is not particularly ambitious, but every description is just a little unnecessarily colourful.

The book is narrated by the heroine of the title, who, in order to help her family in financially difficult times, seeks out positions as a governess despite a sheltered upbringing. The children of both families with whom she resides are unrelentingly cruel, wilful and generally shocking.

The writing seems a little stilted, amateurish – whether this is deliberate in an attempt to lend authenticity to young Agnes’ voice, or inadvertent, it makes the book difficult to get into (not unlike Northanger Abbey). There is a strong tinge of social commentary throughout, which I rather enjoyed – it is more skilfully crafted in The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, but it is still convincing and thought-provoking here, and still applicable today, with mentions of what an author is willing to put in the public domain (Facebook? Blogging? Thought so) and familial tensions. Not having read much 19th century literature, I don’t know whether the relative poverty conveyed is a rare topic, but given her ground-breaking choices in TToWH, it wouldn’t surprise me. The behaviour of the children reminded me very much of the behaviour of a young Helen Keller in a favourite book of mine, Helen Keller’s Teacher.

The criticism of the writing is by no means all-encompassing; Brontë has a magnificent turn of phrase when she cares to use it. Words like “proxility” and “colloquy” and the simple emotions conveyed with “she would rather live in a cottage with Richard Grey than in a palace with any other man in the world” show the class and style I had expected from Agnes after TToWH.

Crucially, the novel has a spectacular ending: “And now I think I have said sufficient.” And so have I.

Reviews from other bloggers: The Captive Reader


1 thought on “5 1/2. Agnes Grey – 7/10”

  1. Yes — I love that ending! I say it all the time now. 🙂

    I felt the book’s topic was ambitious because it’s so blunt. She basically says, “It sucks to be a governess. Anybody care?” Pretty gutsy for a woman living in a little house in the moors. I almost feel like she sacrificed that bluntness about halfway through the story, when the love story begins. I like where she went with it, mind you. But the journalistic delivery of life as a governess kind of fell away.

    I can tell she’s a new writer finding her voice in this novel. And I think that’s pretty cool to read. As a woman, I very much respect Anne.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s